Major Considerations in the Routing of Plastic
By Van Niser
|Before the process of routing or machining
plastic, the user must evaluate the capabilities inherent to the operation.
The first consideration is in the area of
machinery, which can vary widely in the world of plastic fabrication. Machines
of choice include: air and electric routers, pin routers, and CNC machinery.
These types of machines are prevalent in sheet fabrication, thermoforming,
rotational molding and blow molding operations throughout the plastic industry.
Air, electric and pin routers, fall into the
categories of hand fed applications, and present an entirely different set of
circumstances than a CNC application. Since these machines are heavily
influenced by the skill of the individual operators, the tooling material of
choice should be high speed steel or carbide tipped with a steel shank. These
tool materials are more forgiving in a hand fed application, and less likely to
fail than solid carbide, which thrive best in the controlled environment of CNC.
Within hand fed operations, one of the more prevalent machines is the air
router. The air router has some characteristics, which has a direct effect on
the tooling choices. The diagram below, (Figure 1-Air Router Assembly Diagram)
illustrates that the air router has a nose or support bearing, a guard and a
guide bushing. All these features have important functions, but they necessitate
the use of router tooling specific to the air router. These tools must be
manufactured with long enough overall length to bottom out in the collet and
extent beyond the guide bushing while making contact with the work piece. Also,
the tools must be slightly undersized along the entire length of the tool to
pass smoothly through the support or nose bearing. The forcing of on size
tooling through the support bearing alters the bearing and negates the function
of this critical mechanism, which adversely affects the concentricity of the
cutting tool. Consequently, it is important to incorporate tooling properly
toleranced for air routers.
|CNC routers are extremely
popular among plastic fabricators with 3 axis and 5 axis machines fulfilling a
variety of needs. Generally speaking, flat sheet fabricators utilize 3 axis,
while thermoformers with a need to attack multi-shaped parts at an angle,
account for most of the 5 axis machines. Solid carbide is the tooling material
widely utilized because of it’s toughness, and the longevity of the cutting edge
when chipload is properly maximized. Solid carbide router tools are available in
a broad range of geometries and styles. Sheet fabricators usually prefer upcut
spirals to aid in the extraction of potentially soft plastic chips. On the other
hand, thermoformers with formed fixtures tend to use straight edge tooling,
which has a neutral effect on the part. Downcut spirals can be utilized in some
5-axis applications, but the fixturing must be such that the chips fall away
from the part. If the chips cannot fall freely from the part, recutting of
plastic chips can cause welding to occur which is detrimental to the part and
the router tool.
Regardless of the type of machinery utilized, the ability to properly hold the
part is critical. The three methods associated with part holddown include:
mechanical i.e.; clamps, dedicated, and flow-through spoilboard systems.
Dedicated and flow-through are the two most prevalent systems in the area of CNC
routing. Flow-through has become the most popular because of the ease of setup,
but there is no question that the best approach to solidly holding parts is a
properly built dedicated spoilboard. The savings in reworked parts, scrapped
parts and overall cycle time is well worth the effort. (For a complete guide to
spoilboards, please refer to the February/March 2002 issue of the IAPD
Lastly in terms of capability and machinery, the machinery is only as good as
it’s maintenance schedule. The critical maintenance on a router as it relates
cutting tools is the collet. Concentricity of the router tool can only be
accomplished with a clean and well-maintained collet system. (For more
information refer to: Proper Colleting and Collet maintenance February/ March
2003 The IAPD Magazine)
Once capability has been determined in terms of
properly maintained machinery and rigidity of part to be machined, tool
selection becomes paramount. Router tools for plastic cutting are application
and material specific. In almost all cases, one cutting tool cannot be utilized
across a variety of plastic material.
Generally speaking, plastic can be categorized as either hard or soft plastic.
Soft plastic will curl a chip and hard plastic tends to produce a splintered
wedge, which is actually broken off in the machining process. The use of “O”
flute tools in straight and spiral configuration with high rake angles and low
clearance will aid in eliminating the knife marks associated with soft plastic.
Hard plastic is best routed with double edge “V” flutes, spiral “O” flutes with
hard plastic geometry, or two and three edge finishers. These tools along with
the proper chipload produce a crater free finish. Cratering in hard plastic
occurs when the shear strength of the material is exceeded in the routing
aforementioned tooling suggestions are accurate starting points, but extremely
general in nature. For specific tooling recommendations by plastic material, log
onto the Internet at
www.plasticrouting.com. This web site was launched several years ago, and
can be accessed via a link on IAPD’s website at
Once tool selection has been finalized, chipload becomes a critical
consideration. Chipload or the actual thickness of the chip is a function of the
spindle speed (RPM), the travel speed of the cutting tool (IPM), and the number
of cutting edges of the tool. In plastic, there is a very narrow range of
chipload to maximize finish and cycle time. Since finish seems to be one
of the most important factors in machining plastic, the range falls between .004
and .012. However, finish is always a personal decision and some applications
may warrant a larger chipload at the expense of finish to increase productivity.
In other words, do not be limited by the recommended range, but use it as a
material showing up in routing and machine shops everywhere. It is a new
material for many and it cannot be machined with the same tools or same methods
used for metal or wood. The systematic process of considering machine
capability, tool selection, and a functional chipload, which is the outcome of
feed and speed is critical. Once this has been accomplished, the user is
prepared to enter the world of machining plastic with confidence.
If you would like to contribute a question
or topic for a future article, please submit
or fax it to (847) 362-5028.
To view previous articles by Van Niser,
Click here to go back to the PMF feature articles.
Plastics Machining & Fabricating
F: (847) 362-5028